January 28, 2008
Check out this NYTimes article on hardware developed specifically for the third world. I’m not sure how I feel about this. In much of the stuff I’m reading or have read, including the magnificent Spell of the Sensuous by David Abram, there is a significant concern over– again– the way of being that computer-based technology may lead us to (see my last post). Abram specifically talks about the necessity of honoring oral, indigenous cultures who are integrally connected to their physical world in every aspect. Now, of course, not all third world cultures fit this description. But a lot of them do. I don’t know if giving computers to such cultures is philanthropy… or just plain old narcissism….or, at its worst, racism. From the article: Negroponte’s XO laptop reveals a great deal about his worldview and how he and his colleagues perceive the benighted people they seek to enlighten.
Yikes.
January 28th, 2008 at 1:18 pm
I’ve debated this issue (of course I have) with a great friend that spent two years teaching kids about computers in the Dominican Republic. He’s just as torn as you/I/Abrams/Bowers is on the issue. On the one hand, it’s patriarchal to think that our cultures are the ones that “matter”, and on the other, often having this skill allows people to rise out of abject poverty. This is SUCH a tough call, and I’m not doing it justice here.
January 28th, 2008 at 2:17 pm
Exactly. Sigh.
I guess… I’m also just stuck on the need for caution regarding the exponential nature of the technological change.When you think that the Net and all its permutations wasn’t around less than twenty years ago…and good lord, by the way, who would have thought that prescribing antibiotics would result in bacterial superstrains? There’s so much we don’t know…
January 28th, 2008 at 2:22 pm
I agree with Joe. I see the poverty and social inequity of rural life vs. urban life in Costa Rica. There are public schools that have huge pieces of tin missing from the walls/roofs. Is an XO computer the MOST important thing to give them? There is no library-do we bypass BOOKS and go straight to blogs? Here(very southern Pacific coast of CR) they just ran landlines for phones.
Residents had cell phones BEFORE having landlines…..is there something missed in leaping frogging ahead? Does a slower impact from the progression of development help cope with the loss of traditions(a transitional era?)
Something I ponder every year there…..