September 15, 2008
Three Things You Should Never Say in a Middle School Classroom
Posted by Dina under General[9] Comments
1: Let’s play a game.
This is good for a cheap and immediate shock of interest, like a Red Bull shot. The heads come up, the eyes glint for a nanosecond. But if you’ve ever had Red Bull you know the truth: “It gives you wings” translates into “It gives you mild nausea and makes your teeth feel soft.”
Equally wide is the gap between whatever index-card Jeopardy knockoff you have planned and your students’ concept of a real game. The fundamental thing to remember is this: a game, by adolescent definition, is something antithetical to school.
So if you’re going to call it a game, be sure it takes students so far out of their seats, so completely busts the clock-watching with its engagement, that students have no way of contradicting the term. Otherwise, do their preternatural sensitivity to hypocrisy some credit.
Honest substitutes: activity, exercise
2. We’re going to have a party.
There are occasions when the word “party” is acceptable in middle school, usually in a compound noun phrase such as “pizza party,” where the implied desirability of the initial noun (”pizza”) overrides the lame adult misuse of the secondary noun (”party”). These occasions are extremely rare, however. In general, honor again the principle of Fundamental Antithesis.
Honest substitutes: celebration, free time, acknowledgement
3. This will be fun.
Never mind that whatever you’ve got planned is actually going to BE fun. To your students, SAYING it’s going to be fun is tantamount to your vice-principal’s comb-over, both morally and aesthetically.
Honest substitutes:
I think you’ll really like this.
You might find this interesting.
Or the phrase I hope you pull out, because despite all of our frustration at the linguistic goose-stepping our students require, we still love our subject, our classroom, and the light of understanding in our kids:
I think this rocks. Maybe you will too.
September 15th, 2008 at 7:02 pm
Thanks for pointing out the “I think this rocks. Maybe you will too.” line.
I often tell my students, “I’m excited about this, because I absolutely love it. I know I’m a dork, but I hope you enjoy this.” The more excited I am, the more I jump up and down as I say this.
September 15th, 2008 at 7:14 pm
This post so rocks.
September 15th, 2008 at 10:17 pm
Another post that makes it worthwhile to follow your blog. Thanks!
September 15th, 2008 at 11:23 pm
You’re so right. The same goes for 9th and 10th grade. The difference in 11th and 12th grade isn’t that they’ve learned to appreciate the finer things, but rather that they’ve learned to appreciate the lunacy of anyone that would be a high school teacher.
tee hee! it’s still fun!
September 18th, 2008 at 7:07 am
[...] suggests that we should never tell students that we’re going to play a game, suggesting “activity” as an [...]
September 25th, 2008 at 9:28 am
hey dina, thanks for this reminder.
did you read dan’s post about math basketball?
http://blog.mrmeyer.com/?p=723
definite connection to what you wrote.
September 26th, 2008 at 8:39 am
@jeffreygene: yes, I did. Very cool. I did note that he called it an “activity.” Although I do think it qualifies as a true game by my definition.
@Sarah: jumping up and down is fun. I do it a lot, esp. when we hit a poem I love. I wonder if demonstrating our own passion for the subject does more to hook kids into than anything else we do– even via pity.
@teacherninja, Paul, Taylor: thanks for commenting. I love seeing new/newer names pop up.
October 5th, 2008 at 10:36 pm
Or, with mock disbelief and then a manic grin: “You don’t like quadratic equations? Really?? Then I’ll have to be excited for two!” You get a grudging smile for that, at least.
October 24th, 2008 at 12:25 pm
@H: manic grins and laughter are key. Dr. Evil from the Austin Powers is a good model.