March 9, 2009
I finished Tracy Kidder’s Mountains Beyond Mountains over the weekend, his biography of Dr. Paul Farmer, and it’s working its way in like a splinter. A lot of the inspiration that sticks these days is from writing that is about medicine, or business– anything but teaching. Maybe subconsciously I don’t trust teachers who have time to write. (Yeah, yeah, I know. Shut up.)
Paul Farmer keeps his head organized in an undeniably low-tech fashion:
On the wall beside his desk, Farmer has taped up three sheets of yellow legal lined paper, on every line a task to be completed, and beside each of these a hand-drawn box, in Creole a bwat. [...] The list on the wall contains about sixty imperatives– to assemble the slides for upcoming speeches, to get Lazarus a Bible and nail clippers, to give another patient the wristwatch he bought for him in the Miami airport, to obtain sputum samples from some of the patients with drug-resistant TB and take them to Boston for testing.
I love the word “bwat,” by the way: it has that mudball-splat, no-way-to-get-wussy-about-it sound that should accompany crossing items off a list. How much of genius, I wonder, is just having the tenacity to slug through your checklist, longer and harder than other people?
It appears Farmer works on completing these lists as methodically as he makes them:
We got to the airport early for once, and went to a cafe for breakfast. “Okay,” Farmer said, when we found a table, “time to get to work.” He pulled out his most recent bwat list. Only about two-thirds of the little boxes had been checked. “This is shameful.” He stared at the sheets of paper. “All these bwats were supposed to be done before we left Cuba.”
…which, I think, suggests something important. Farmer insists on a worldview where the universal right to health makes such terms as “cost-effectiveness,” “appropriate technology,” and “triage” absurd. It is a world where decisions about what is accomplished are only defined more or less by what fate happens to put in front of you, as Farmer comments in the case of spending $20,000 to medivac a Haitian patient to Boston.
“The bottom line is, why do we intervene as aggressively as we can with that kid and not with another? Because his mother brought him to us and that’s where he was, at our clinic.”
I don’t pretend to have anywhere near the life-and-death impact of Dr. Farmer in my own line of work. But I would not be a public school teacher if I did not believe in another, similarly universal right of human beings.
I also have a checklist. I triage it daily.
What if I didn’t?
March 10th, 2009 at 6:15 am
But what if your checklist is full of bwats that totally suck? I mean, Cheney probably had a list of things to do. Deeper philosophy will guide the bwats, and that seems more important to me. Farmer’s philosophy is most excellent, but it’s also not a life that I could live.
Bwat. Great word.
March 10th, 2009 at 7:26 pm
I need to get this book on my to-read list. I love Kidder’s book, a love that comes naturally in my family. He’s one of two authors by whom my father owns every book hardback.
I need to figure out a way to be this organized. Where would that list of to-dos with bwats be? In my classroom? At home? In my plan book? I have to solve that problem first, sadly.
March 11th, 2009 at 5:31 am
I also like using literature from outside of the educational canon to inform my practice.
Actually, I regularly see educational bloggers relying on non-educators to make decisions about teaching and curriculum.
I think it’s a good thing.
March 20th, 2009 at 8:16 pm
Dina,
Paul Farmer is one of my heroes. His relentless focus on his mission made me ashamed to admit that I am doing less than I can at any given moment. On the other hand, do you recall the scene where he tells his donor (can’t remember the name) that quitting his job and coming to work in Haiti would, for the donor, be a sin? That gentleman was really good at making money and really good at giving it away. So, I don’t have to be Paul Farmer, but I have to be really good at giving and at using my gifts in service. And always keep the mission at the forefront.
I really enjoy your blog and I don’t comment much, so I just wanted to tell you that. I think you are a top quartile teacher (and I was okay at math).
Sarah